Mama Drama

Yesterday I read three great posts by three amazing women. All three women wrote about making a choice for their family. And all three had to put statement in their posts saying something to the effect of “Please don’t judge me. I’m doing what’s best for my family, not what’s best for your’s.”

Go read them! They are awesome! Jill from Baby Rabies wrote about crying it out, Suzanne from Bebeh Blog wrote about weaning off breast feeding, and Katie from Sluiter Nation wrote about choosing to have a repeat c-section.

Back again? Ok, so, back to my point. These women are making choices that work for their families. They have done their research. They know what works. They know what WON’T work. And yet, they still felt the need to add disclaimers about WHY they are making these decisions to prevent Judgy McJudgersons from making them feel crappy about their decisions.

This HAS to stop. It has to. If there is one thing I cannot stand is fellow mothers telling other mothers that what they are doing is completely WRONG and that they will mess up their child by making whatever choice they have made.

Who ARE these women who think they have all the answers? And why must they make other women feel bad for the choices they have made?

Look, we’re all struggling out there. None of us knew what we were truly getting into when we had our babies. We are all looking for help raising our children the best we can. I’m a full supporter of the statement ”It takes a village to raise a child.” But when that village vilifies you and says you are essentially screwing up your child by making whatever choice you’ve made? So not helpful.

It’s not just found here in our blogging communities. Nope. It’s everywhere. Women giving rude glances or disparaging remarks to a mother mixing a bottle of formula at the mall (“Breast is best!”). Other women giving other rude glances to a mother breast feeding her child at the mall (“Put those away and give the kid a bottle!”). Shoot, even Anderson Cooper is doing a segment this week on his show about how some women think stay at home moms are lazy! (BA did a great job writing about this over at Babble)

Yeah, the comments to that story are UNREAL. I read one in which a woman said that if anything, working moms are lazy because they are pawning their children off on others to raise them so they can selfishly further their careers and go to the gym and out for happy hour.

STOP IT STOP IT STOP IT STOP IT.

We are all raising our children in ways that work for our families. It doesn’t have to work for your family. What’s good for the goose might not be so good for the gander!

Please, if someone asks for advice on how to get their child to sleep, feel free to offer it. When you get that advice, remember that whatever that person is telling you, that’s what worked for THEM and that it might not work for YOU. If someone is coming out and saying, “This is my decision” the only response from you should be, “Good for you!” or, if you can’t say that, then say NOTHING. It is not an invitation for you to jump in and tell that person they are making a bad decision or it’d be better if they chose something else. It’s not your place.

I shouldn’t have to write a blog post about it. I shouldn’t. We should all be supportive of each other no matter what. So please, stop the Mama Drama. Stop judging others for making decisions that are different than the ones you have made. The ONLY THING that you know, is what works for you. That’s it.

::steps off soapbox::

  • Katie

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    ::stands up applauding::

    Nikki, you have NO IDEA how badly I did NOT want to put that disclaimer. How I didn’t even want to have to discuss it, really. I mean I couldn’t believe how many people cared how my baby was going to come out.

    I read Jill’s post too. We didn’t use the CIO method with Eddie, but it doesn’t mean we would never use it. Nor does it mean it doesn’t work for others.

    It makes me so sad that we have to post these things on the defense and not just as a narrative of what our plan is for the sheer purpose of sharing our experiences with each other.

    I was lucky to get the support I did in the comments, on twitter, and on facebook. I plan to lay it out there why we bottle feed too…I am not expecting near the support, unfortunately. :(

    Thank you for being a great friend who supports rather than judges…no matter how similar or different our methods/choices may be.

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      I think it sucks that those disclaimers have to go up. It sucks that there are women out there who think their parenting poop doesn’t stink. We write these things to find community. To find support. I LOVED your post because it gave ME the support I’ll need. It sucks that women are so willing to give negative comments when what we are really looking for is support.

      And really, when our kids get to school, is there really going to be that outstanding of a difference between them? Shoot, you’re a teacher! Can you pin-point the kids that were Feberized vs. the kids that co-slept? Probably not! They are probably all (mostly) well-adjusted kids. Or young adults. They probably don’t want to be called kids ;)

    • Teri

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      Katie, please know that there are two communities that support bottle feeding parents: Bottle Babies on Facebook and The Fearless Formula Feeder’s blog and Facebook page. If you’re not getting the support you need, I encourage you to check out both communities. It’s inexcusable that anyone should give you a hard time for bottle feeding, but unfortunately that’s where “breast is best” has gotten the parenting world. One-size-fits-all medicine is not best for anyone.

  • Jessica

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    I read all of those posts yesterday and I’m just not sure what happened to “if you don’t have anything nice to say don’t say anything”? Read it, if you don’t like it, close the page and move ON! Mom’s need support not judgement, every mom does what she needs to for HER family.

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      Exactly! If you don’t agree with something, fine. No need to throw flames out there. Just click the red X or walk on by.

  • Kristen

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Awesome post. Love. It. You are so right about the bullying. Why do people care so much? Great post.

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      Thank you!

      I never thought that as a mother I’d see so much bullying from other mothers! I thought that by now we would have all grown out of it. And really, I don’t know why people care so darn much and why they have to be so loud and mean about it :(

  • Elizabeth Flora Ross

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    I couldn’t agree more. Please come join our community. We are trying to put an end to all this madness!

    http://themompledge.com

    Would be proud to have you as a member. And I’m going right now to post this on our FB page…

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      Thank you so much! I’m proud to be a new member of this community!

  • Tracie

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Yes yes yes!!

    The judging really does need to stop.

  • R's Mom

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Awesome post! I read Katie’s post yesterday (but hadn’t read the others yet). And I love Katie’s blog! But I really had to refrain from commenting, because I didn’t want what I posted to seem critical of her, her choice, or her post…but you hit the nail on the head about what was bothering me about the post.

    Why did she feel like she needed to put a disclaimer and justify her repeat c-section? Why are other moms so judgmental of the choices we make for ourselves and our family? I don’t mean this to critical of Katie AT ALL for deciding to post, but more as a criticism of those people that made her feel like she needed to justify and have excuses for her decision. Because by making her feel like she needs to justify her decision, it gives a little validity to the side of the argument that not having a c-section is the right approach, unless there is a really, really good reason.

    And for the record, R was born via c-section…for largely the exact same reasons that Katie’s Eddie was born via c-section. And if I have another baby, he/she will be born via c-section, as I am not comfortable with the risks of a VBAC. End of story, my choice.

    Thanks for a great post! I just found your blog from Katie’s link on twitter, and I look forward to exploring it more!

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      Thanks for visiting today, and thanks for commenting :)

      I completely agree with you. By any of us putting a disclaimer out there like that, it does seem like admitting that we’ve made the unpopular choice. But really, it’s just us putting on our flame retardant suits and gearing up for whatever sancti-mommies throw our way.

  • Andrea

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Awesome post! And soooo agree! We should be lifting each other up not tearing down. It is not our place to judge anyone.

  • Suzanne

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Thank you Nicci, both for saying this and for including my post. I am lucky that my corner of the internet is small and very supportive of my choices – even when they aren’t the same ones people have made for their families.

    I have to admit though, that when I was a new mom of my first baby I made a LOT of judgments when it came to other people’s parenting. Sometimes the thoughts popped into my head so fast I couldn’t even stop them. But instead of saying them out loud (or typing them on someone’s blog) I kept them to myself. And BOY HOWDY am I glad I did, because after having a second baby I TRULY understand how different one kid can be from another and how one person’s experience is NOT MINE and their choices, even under what seem to be the same set of circumstances, are not mine to judge.

    Wouldn’t it be nice if we could learn that lesson before we ever even thought about having kids?

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      You’re welcome :) Thanks for writing it!

      And you know what makes you different from those women? You kept your judgments TO YOURSELF! There are MANY times I read a blog post or hear about a mother doing something I don’t agree with. But I keep to myself knowing that if someone were to come at ME like that, I’d be hurt.

  • Practical Parenting

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    All families are different. We need to accept and be open to learning from and with one another instead of judging.

  • Jill @BabyRabies

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Thank you for the shout out and support! I KNOW that women like us, mothers like us are not in the minority. It’s just that the ones who are self righteous and judgemental are quicker to speak out and louder. Many times, those of us who are supportive and empathetic keep quiet just so we don’t have to deal with the drama. That’s a big reason why I wrote my post yesterday. I’m tired of staying quiet. I want other moms going through similar situations to know I’m there, I’ve been through it, I’m struggling, too. They are NOT alone.

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      We’re not the minority, that’s true, thankfully! We’re just the quiet minority. We don’t stir the pot and thus don’t get the attention that the negative people do.

      And I LOVE that you wrote that and that Katie and Suzanne wrote their posts, too. We have to stop hiding our decisions for fear of ridicule and branch out for support!

  • Angie Matthewson

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    No, you shouldn’t have to write it. But thank you for doing so. Well said. I should go read the cry-it-out post. I did it for the first 8 months, then I couldn’t take it. I felt such guilt for rocking my baby back to sleep. Even though I loved it! It seemed like everyone I told shook their heads & said “don’t start down that road!” Well, it’s worked for me. We all sleep better, and she’s a great kid! I am so happy for people if they find something that works for them & their kids. I’m glad I finally embraced what works for me! :)

  • Lyz

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    Unfortunately, I don’t think it will ever stop. As long as people have an opinion there will be others out there to make them feel like crap for it. It happens in all areas of life, but I think it’s most sensitive in parenting decisions where what we do and don’t do affects the outcome of someone’s life, therefore the stakes are higher. Of course, this doesn’t make it right. But I don’t think there has ever been a point in history when there wasn’t a crazy person trying to make someone feel like crap for something. You know those French newspapers were all “Marie Antoinette is not breastfeeding. WORST MOM EVER!” But in French…

    • Nicci

      January 10th, 2012

      Reply

      My mom and I talked about this for quite a bit this morning. Back when I was a newborn, she got looks and comments for FFing me. The difference was she wasn’t putting her choices onto the internet where people can hid behind the anonymity of a computer screen. Sancti-mommies existed 30 years ago, and they’ll be around 30 years from now. As long as there are different methods of parenting, there will be people who think their methods are best, unfortunately.

  • Jenny

    January 10th, 2012

    Reply

    It shouldn’t have to be said, but it needed to be said. i loved this. I get so defensive when I feel like someone is judging my parenting choices.

  • Arnebya

    January 11th, 2012

    Reply

    I try my best not to add disclaimers. I say what I feel and how I mean it and hope people get it (all the while hoping no one judges and certainly wishing no one is ballsy enough to actually say looka here, stupid, you’re ruining your kids). I don’t censor myself when I know I’ve done like the writers you mention: researched and decided what’s best for ME. Thank you for this post. It is well needed and hopefully much read.

  • I’m trying not to Lash Out

    January 11th, 2012

    Reply

    [...] stay out?  Would you have judged another mother? (Because I will also admit that I read another excellent post about Moms supporting each other and NOT calling one another [...]

  • [...] And instead of lending a sympathetic ear, or offering at least a token of understanding, mothers with different points of view attack one another (in varying degrees of literacy) screaming about child abuse (when there is none) and undercutting any self confidence a mother might have about her decision. This happens so often that these exchanges have been titled “Mommy Wars” and apparently have become so popular that many parenting blogs are begging for them to stop. [...]

Leave a Comment

* are Required fields